• Language

  • 141 E Palm Lane, Suite 100,
    Phoenix, AZ 85004
    Ph: (602) 234-0782

    Joe Dana Blog

    What would you decide? Deport or pardon?

    What if you were the administrator at the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Phoenix headquarters who on Monday will hear the appeal of Maria and Felix Cardenas?
    Consider the case. In 1993 Maria and Felix crossed the desert and worked several years for a local windows manufacturer. They have never returned to Mexico.
    Today, the couple has two Mexican-born adult children living here and a 10 year-old American born son, Felix Jr. The older children carry work permits and are in the process of applying for long-term residency.
    But Maria and Felix are scheduled to be deported next week.
    On Monday they will apply for a coveted legal loophole known as “cancellation of removal.” It is their final hope.
    The provision is available to illegal immigrants who have been in the country at least ten years and who have shown good moral character. They also must prove that removal would result in “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” to an immediate family member who is a U.S. citizen or permanent resident.
    Maria and Felix argue that they don’t have criminal records and that their children are likely to stay in the U.S. for life.
    They also contend that if they are deported, Felix Jr. would suffer “exceptional and unusual hardship”.
    Several years ago Felix Jr. was diagnosed with a mental disorder and learning disability. As a U.S. citizen, Felix Jr. receives state social services for treatment. If he were to be uprooted to Mexico he would likely severely regress, his parents say.
    “He (Felix Jr.) doesn’t want to leave,” says Maria. “He’s just ten years old. If we are deported, we would probably have to leave him behind with my other children. But I don’t know if we could stand to do that.”
    Adding to the couple’s dilemma is the fact that, if deported, they would not be able to return to the U.S. for ten years.
    I mentioned to the family’s attorney, Monika Sud-Devaraj, that many Arizonans who learn of the family’s story will not have sympathy because the couple came here illegally. Decisions have consequences, many will say.
    Sud-Devaraj said she understands the sentiment and she doesn’t believe in blanket “amnesty.” But she points out that the U.S. Justice Department announced last year a shift in policy to focus on deporting illegal immigrants with criminal records. Then earlier this year President Obama announced that foreign-born children of illegal immigrants, dubbed by some as “dreamers”, should be allowed to obtain work permits if they meet certain requirements.
    “Lots of people have come here illegally. Mr. Obama’s policy right now is ‘let’s not worry about them (Maria and Felix). They’re honest hardworking people.’ If we were talking about a criminal, it’s a different issue,” Sud-Devaraj said.
    On Monday, nobody’s opinion will matter except that of one very influential ICE administrator. What would you decide?

    This entry was posted in News. Bookmark the permalink.

    3 Responses to Joe Dana Blog

    1. Minnie says:

      Greetings from Colorado! I’m boreed to tears
      at worrk so I decided tto browse your website on my iphone
      during
      lunch break. I enjoy the knowledge yoou
      provide here and can’t waiit to take a look when Igett home.

      I’m amazed at how quick your blog loaded on
      my mobipe .. I’m
      not even uing WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, fantastic blog!

    2. stick war says:

      We stumbled over here coming from a different web address and thought
      I should check things out. I like what I see so i am just following
      you. Look forward to going over your web page yet again.

    3. Everyone loves what you guys are usually up too. This type of clever work and reporting!
      Keep up the amazing works guys I’ve added you guys to my personal blogroll.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



    Our Attorneys

    • Monika Sud-Devaraj
      Email: monika@msdlawaz.com

        Email: monika@msdlawaz.com   Ms. Monika Sud-Devaraj received her JD degree in 1992 from the University of Arizona, College of Law in Tucson, Arizona. She...

      View Bio

    • Roberta Wilson
      Email: roberta@msdlawaz.com

        Email: roberta@msdlawaz.com   Ms. Wilson left the state of Montana to attend college at the University of Arizona in 1997. There she developed a healthy...

      View Bio

    Areas of Practice

    • Immigration Law

        Before we can schedule a telephone or e-mail consultation with you, please complete this form. The information you provide using this form is for the...

      Read more
    • Criminal Law

      Before we can schedule a telephone or e-mail consultation with you, please complete this form. The information you provide using this form is for the sole use...

      Read more

    Recent Posts

    • Joe Dana Blog
      September 7th, 2012

      What would you decide? Deport or pardon? What if you were the administrator at the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Phoenix headquarters who on Monday will hear the appeal of Maria and Felix Cardenas? Consider the case. In 1993 Maria and Felix crossed the desert and worked several years for a local windows manufacturer. They have never...

    • Attorney
      February 18th, 2012

      Ms. Sud-Devaraj was born in New Delhi, India, but has spent most of her entire life in the United States. She is admitted to practice before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and is a member of the Arizona State Bar Association, the American Immigration Lawyers Association and the Maricopa County Bar Association....